5 Measurable Criteria for an Employee Recognition Program

One of the reasons why expert managers will always be prized above metrics and award ceremonies is that they can recognize the intangible qualities in each team member. They understand and recognize the effect each team member has on the business and the task at hand.

One of the sad things about modern human resources is that such qualities are so difficult to measure. After all, how do you measure a positive attitude, an indomitable spirit, or innovative thought? This article offers five employee recognition criteria for employee recognition programs that are measurable, perhaps so that lesser recognized employees may have a chance to shine through effective employee recognition programs. By recognizing employees in a structured way, companies can boost morale and productivity.

1. Attendance Recognition

Perhaps one of the easiest elements to measure in employee recognition programs is attendance. Try not to factor punctuality into these sorts of things because sometimes people are late for very good reasons, be it broken-down buses or medical emergencies.

People who turn up for work when they are supposed to over the course of a year could be rewarded in some way. It is a very easy metric to measure, and since staff absence is a big problem for most companies, it may be nice for regular attenders to receive some sort of recognition award as part of their employee recognition. Consider implementing recognition award examples such as "Perfect Attendance" certificates or small bonuses.

How this recognition system is set up should have certain levels of leeway. For example, staff should be able to work back their missed days. They shouldn't be penalized for refusing to come in on days they were not originally scheduled for. Also, a buffer zone may be installed, such that if people miss up to three days per year, they are still eligible for the attendance recognition reward. This approach can significantly boost employee engagement and motivation.

2. Classic KPI Recognition

The type of key performance indicator (KPI) recognition each company sets up will depend on the company itself and the roles that employees are undertaking. For example, salespeople may be judged and rewarded for how many sales they make over a certain dollar value. Factory operatives may be recognized for how many units they make. These are examples of recognition criteria that can be easily measured and incorporated into employee recognition programs.

There are many jobs where hard-target KPIs are not applicable, but in cases where one employee's success isn't at the expense of another employee's success, then KPI recognition may work well. Setting up this system requires a close examination of the facts. For example, staff shouldn't be able to fake orders or steal other employees' work to mark down as their own. Also, you may have to account for times when there simply isn't enough work to do; in that employees shouldn't be punished for not making units when there are no orders for units.

Variable targets may be applicable on a day-to-day basis, so long as they are fair and the staff understands they are fair. This approach can significantly boost employee satisfaction and motivation. Consider implementing  employee rewards based on KPI achievements to further incentivize performance.

Want to learn how Workmates can transform your organization today?

Book Your Free Demo

3. Milestones Crossed Recognition

If a business has a working process that is somewhat predictable, then milestone rewards can be useful. They are especially handy in companies where gamification has taken hold. Just like in a game, a milestone may come with recognition, be it processing 100 orders, or working 100 hours, or something similar. This form of employee recognition can be particularly effective for boosting team morale and fostering a sense of achievement. Consider implementing recognition awards for reaching significant milestones as part of your employee recognition program.

The milestones must be things that employees will achieve as long as they keep working there. The fact that they are inevitable milestones makes the tasks being undertaken a little more meaningful. A deep understanding of the employee's work cycle is required to correctly install a milestone recognition program. This is especially true in areas where some employees undertake certain tasks as milestones when others do not.

You do not want your employees having to take time out to work in different departments just to get their milestone rewards. Also, be aware of tapering off the milestones for long-term employees. For example, milestone rewards for 6 months service, 1-year service, 2-year service and 5-year service is a little unfair on your long-term employees. Consider implementing a service recognition program that continues to value and appreciate employees throughout their tenure. Look at various recognition program examples to find inspiration for your own milestone-based rewards system.

4. Positive Reviews Recognition

This sort of recognition is common in call centers and can be an excellent example of spot recognition. Callers are often asked if they would like to stay on the line and give a review after each call. Those who receive good reviews are rewarded. A similar feature is becoming more common with live chat employees. After the live chat is over, the customer is asked to complete a quick survey to give their opinion. Review features are common within these surveys and can be used as part of recognition programs and perhaps as training tools.

There are many ways this sort of thing can be exploited. Make sure your staff are not doing the Wells Fargo employee trick of setting up fake accounts so they can set up their own positive reviews. Plus, do not forget that employees can hire Chinese click farms for just a few dollars and have automated reviews set up with some online systems. Implementing robust recognition tools can help prevent such misuse and ensure fair employee recognition. This approach can be one of the best employee recognition methods as it directly ties customer satisfaction to employee performance.

Consider incorporating peer recognition into this system as well. Colleagues can provide valuable employee feedback that complements customer reviews, creating a more comprehensive picture of an employee's performance. Associate recognition programs that combine customer and peer feedback can be particularly effective in fostering a culture of excellence.

5. Money Saved Recognition

Do be careful because this sort of recognition program is open to abuse, but there are many ways that companies and uncaring employees can waste money. For example, leaving air conditioning units on in empty rooms or trashing broken products rather than trying to reclaim working parts.

Do not make this a competitive recognition and rewards program. Make it more of a system that rewards people for repeatedly doing the right thing, rather than trying to push them to innovate with regard to saving money. Perhaps set up a series of rules and protocols. If they are followed, then the staff member is recognized. This is especially useful in cases where being wasteful is faster. Just make sure it cannot be exploited, such as when staff purposefully order too much of a resource, so that they can claim bigger quantities of savings when they "don't" use a said product in their process. This type of recognition can align well with company values and contribute to a positive workplace culture. Consider implementing creative recognition program ideas that encourage cost-saving behaviors without compromising quality or efficiency.

Conclusion - Don't Let Your Recognition Program Cause Damage

There are many ways you can cause more damage than good with a recognition program. The most common problem is staff anger and dissent when seemingly work-shy or sycophantic employees are recognized. Another common problem is where the recognition itself causes staff to become disillusioned and outright angry. Such as when people have not missed a single day of work in five years, and their "Recognition" is common in the team newsletter.

When done correctly, employee recognition programs can do a lot of good and show your employees that they are truly valued. They can significantly improve employee engagement, reduce employee turnover, and enhance the overall employee experience. Consider using digital employee recognition platforms to streamline the process and ensure consistency across your organization. Remember, the goal of any recognition strategy should be to foster a positive company culture, boost employee motivation, and ultimately drive better performance management.

To maximize the impact of your employee recognition activities, consider implementing global recognition programs that cater to diverse teams across different locations. This approach ensures that all employees feel appreciated, regardless of their geographical location. Additionally, organizing regular recognition events can help reinforce the importance of employee appreciation and create memorable experiences for your staff.

When developing your recognition strategy, it's crucial to consider the return on investment. Measuring the recognition ROI can help you justify the resources allocated to these programs and continuously improve their effectiveness. By focusing on creating the best employee recognition program possible, you can foster a culture of appreciation that drives both individual and organizational success.

Experience how Workmates can transform communication and strengthen culture—all in one powerful platform

Book Your Free Demo