Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)
Stock appreciation rights (SARs) give an employee the right to receive the increase in a company's stock value over a set period, without buying the shares. The payout equals the difference between the grant price and the price at exercise.
Corporate Finance Institute's SAR guide describes a SAR as a right to compensation equal to an increase in the company's stock price over a base. Employers use SARs as a flexible form of equity-based pay.
How Do Stock Appreciation Rights Work?
The company grants a number of SARs with a base price, usually the stock price on the grant date. The SARs vest over time, often over several years.
After vesting, the employee exercises the SARs. The payout is the stock price at exercise minus the base price, multiplied by the number of SARs.
Example: an employee holds 100 SARs with a $10 base price. If the stock reaches $50, the gain is $40 per SAR, or $4,000 in total.
What Is the Difference Between Cash-Settled and Stock-Settled SARs?
A cash-settled SAR pays the gain in cash. A stock-settled SAR pays the gain in shares of company stock.
Cash settlement is simple and works for private companies with no ready market for shares. Stock settlement conserves cash but dilutes other shareholders.
The plan must say which method applies, and some plans let the company choose at exercise.
How Are SARs Taxed?
Corporate Finance Institute notes that SARs are generally subject to the same tax treatment as non-qualified stock options. The employee typically recognizes ordinary income at exercise, and the employer handles withholding.
Employees do not owe tax at grant or vesting in the usual case. Tax comes when they exercise and receive value.
Tax rules are detailed and change, so review them with a tax adviser. This page is general information.
How Do SARs Compare With Stock Options and Phantom Stock?
| Feature | SARs | Stock options | Phantom stock |
| Employee buys shares | No | Yes, at the exercise price | No |
| Reward based on | Growth above base price | Growth above exercise price | Full value or growth |
| Payout form | Cash or shares | Shares | Cash |
| Ownership | None unless settled in shares | Real shares after exercise | None |
The stock options entry explains how options work and how ISOs and NSOs are taxed differently.
Why Do Employers Use SARs?
SARs reward growth without asking employees to pay to exercise. That removes the cash barrier that options can create.
For the company, cash-settled SARs avoid issuing shares and keep ownership unchanged. They are also easy to customize for a small group.
The tradeoff is a future cash cost that rises with the stock price. See the equity compensation entry for how SARs fit among other equity awards.
When Do SARs Make Sense?
SARs suit companies that want equity-style rewards without issuing shares. Private companies and companies close to their share limits often prefer them to options.
They also help when employees cannot afford to exercise options. Because SARs require no purchase, the employee receives value without paying out of pocket.
The tradeoff is cost certainty. With cash-settled SARs, a rising stock price increases the company's cash obligation, so finance should model the exposure before granting.
What Should Employees Know Before Accepting SARs?
Ask how the base price is set and how the value of the company is determined. For private companies, the valuation method drives the payout.
Find out when you can exercise and what happens if you leave. Many plans limit the time you have to exercise after departure.
Ask whether payment is in cash or shares and how taxes are withheld. The answers decide how much you actually take home.
Finally, keep your own record of the grant date, the base price, and the vesting schedule. Having the numbers on hand makes it easier to plan the timing of an exercise and to check that each statement is correct.
How Does HR Cloud Fit Into SARs?
HR Cloud does not administer SARs or equity plans. Its People page describes a single source of truth for job, pay, and performance data for employee records.
Use an equity administration platform to track grants, vesting, and exercise.
Discover how our HR solutions streamline onboarding, boost employee engagement, and simplify HR management
Book Your Free DemoFrequently Asked Questions
Q: What are stock appreciation rights?
A: SARs give the holder the increase in company stock value over a base price, without buying shares.
Q: How is a SAR payout calculated?
A: It equals the stock price at exercise minus the base price, multiplied by the number of SARs.
Q: Do SARs require the employee to buy stock?
A: No. The employee receives the gain in cash or shares and does not pay an exercise price.
Q: Are SARs taxed like stock options?
A: Generally yes. SARs usually follow the same tax treatment as non-qualified stock options, with income recognized at exercise.
Q: What is the difference between SARs and phantom stock?
A: SARs pay the growth above a base price. Phantom stock more often pays the full value of units, though plans vary.
Q: Can private companies grant SARs?
A: Yes. Cash-settled SARs suit private companies because they do not require issuing shares.
Keep Reading
Ready to streamline your onboarding process?
Book a demo today and see how HR Cloud can help you create an exceptional experience for your new employees.
Book Your Free Demo