Rewards vs. Recognition: Key Differences and Why Both Are Important

Job satisfaction is crucial to getting optimal effort from your employees and achieving maximum productivity. 

According to The Conference Board’s 2023 survey, 62.3% of US employees felt satisfaction with their jobs, the highest number since surveys started in 1987. 

This number tells a story of HR teams nationwide paying more attention to achieving employee engagement and retention. 

Employee satisfaction extends beyond paying workers handsomely or setting up a comfortable workspace. Many other factors contribute to the employee experience, ultimately influencing job satisfaction. 

Reward and recognition are two key factors in a comprehensive reward and recognition strategy. Here, we'll explore employee reward vs recognition, how they differ, and their importance for a positive employee experience and workplace recognition. 

What’s the Difference Between Employee Rewards and Recognition?

HR personnel often interchange employee rewards and staff recognition. While both concepts complement each other in employee rewards and recognition programs, they’re not the same and won’t work as substitutes for each other in your workplace.

Though employee rewards and recognition are both viable means of appreciating employees, the activities involved are usually different.

Employee Rewards

As the name suggests, rewards refer to tangible benefits you offer employees in response to their performance or achievements. 

These incentives may include financial bonuses, gift cards, paid vacations, promotions, or material possessions like company-branded merchandise.

Generally, you give rewards to acknowledge the achievement of specific goals or objectives. The primary intention is to motivate employees to perform at a higher level.  As such, rewards in the workplace often serve as extrinsic motivators to drive desired behaviors and outcomes.

Employee Recognition

Employee recognition is a more abstract concept involving acknowledging and appreciating an employee's efforts, contributions, or achievements. While rewards usually feature an incentive, the prize in employee recognition is the action itself.

A common form of recognition involves publicly commending individuals or teams for their hard work, dedication, or positive impact. Recognition may come as verbal or written appreciation, public announcements, awards, or symbolic gestures like a round of applause.

It’s important to remember that recognition should come from multiple directions. As an employer or manager, you should make sure you celebrate your team's good work. But,  alongside this, you should also use tools like recognition software to provide a public feed where fellow workmates can show appreciation to each other through peer-to-peer recognition. 

Unlike rewards, recognition focuses on intrinsic motivation by fulfilling the basic human need for validation and a sense of belonging.

One platform for culture, communication, and employee recognition.

See the Workmates Difference

Other Differences Between Employee Reward and Recognition

• Rewards feature tangible incentives, while recognition is mostly abstract.

• Rewards are conditional and often transactional because you give them in response to an action or achievement. Conversely, recognition is relational because you give it to appreciate the individual (you don’t need a specific reason to do it).

• Rewards usually appeal in an economic sense and have physical utility, while recognition appeals in an emotional sense and offers a positive psychological impact.

Inherently, these concepts sound like two sides of the same coin, and, in most cases, one often precedes the other. Remember, however, that neither is a substitute for the other, and it’s important to give adequate rewards and recognition to your employees where due.

The Importance of Employee Rewards

Rewards enhance employee motivation, engagement, and overall job satisfaction. Let's explore the benefits of employee rewards and recognition programs:

Increased Motivation 

Rewards serve as powerful motivators for employees. Giving tangible incentives to your workers when they achieve a predetermined objective indicates that you want them to continue creating such results.

In addition, rewards also serve as compensation for effort and time invested in an activity. 

In the future, the expectation of an incentive will encourage your employees to recreate a result, even if it means going the extra mile. 

Improved Productivity

Using potential rewards as a motivator often translates to increased performance from employees. And, since you set the incentive, you determine what operational goals employees must achieve to receive it. 

This makes it easy to help employees achieve more for the company; you only need to set goals in line with the productivity metrics you want them to hit.

Also, when employees feel valued and know you’ll acknowledge and reward their hard work, they’re more likely to invest time and energy into their tasks. The result of this is increased productivity and efficiency in the workplace.

Increased Employee Engagement

Nothing gets staff entrenched in work culture like the promise of a reward for their actions. Employee rewards contribute to higher levels of staff engagement, among other things. 

Engaged employees are committed to their work, passionate about their roles, and aligned with organizational goals.

Even when they hit roadblocks, engaged staff are more motivated to circumvent these obstacles to reach their goal quicker. They have a clear picture of the prize and won’t let anything stop them from getting it.

Why Employee Recognition Matters for the Employee Experience 

Here’s why you need employee recognition initiatives as part of your workplace culture and recognition strategies:

Employees Feel Valued and Appreciated

While a reward is an extrinsic motivator, recognition appeals to emotions and the intrinsic human desire to be noticed. As such, it makes employees feel welcome, wanted, and needed.

This fosters a sense of belonging and camaraderie, making workers feel like they’re contributing significantly to a common cause. For example, if you use recognition software, it has the double effect of recognizing employees' hard work whilst fostering an environment of appreciation and positivity. 

Knowing their input is crucial and also makes employees self-motivated to do more.

Makes Employees Take Pride in Their Contributions

Employee recognition and appreciation target the human ego, massaging the average person’s pride. When you give due recognition to staff, you give them the ultimate respect.

Naturally, they’ll then take greater pride in their work, growing confident in their workplace contributions. They’ll also have more conviction in their actions going forward.

The need to protect their ego can also spur employees to go the extra mile in the future.

Best Practices for Leveraging Employee Rewards & Recognition Programs

Employee rewards and recognition programs are powerful tools for motivating and engaging workers. Here are some best practices to leverage these programs and significantly impact satisfaction and employee loyalty:

Set Clear Objectives and Criteria

Before launching a rewards and recognition program, establish clear objectives and criteria. 

Define the behaviors, achievements, or milestones you intend to recognize and reward. Ensure these criteria align with the company's values, goals, and desired outcomes.

Clear guidelines will help create a fair and transparent program that employees can understand and work toward.

Practice Timely and Specific Recognition

Recognition loses its impact when it’s delayed or generalized, so provide timely and specific recognition for employee achievements or contributions. 

Acknowledge individual employee efforts as soon as possible, and be specific about what they did well.

For example, don’t just say "Good job." Instead, say, "Excellent work on completing the project ahead of schedule. Your attention to detail, teamwork, and remarkable use of the virtual telephone system were instrumental in its success."

Practice Inclusive and Fair Distribution

Ensure that rewards and recognition are distributed fairly and inclusively across the organization. 

Recognize achievements at all levels, from frontline employees to managers and executives. Avoid bias and ensure the program encompasses all workers, including celebrating work anniversaries and offering service awards.

Celebrate Milestones and Achievements

Apart from day-to-day recognition, celebrate significant milestones and achievements memorably. 

Organize special events, ceremonies, or team-building activities to honor major accomplishments or project completions. 

 Employee appreciation events create a sense of pride, foster camaraderie, and encourage a culture of excellence.

Employee Reward and Recognition Are Both Important

Employee rewards and recognition both matter. They increase motivation and improve productivity, translating to better job satisfaction, employee engagement, and employee retention. 

The difference is that employee rewards are more physical, often taking the form of tangible benefits. Conversely, employee recognition is abstract, appealing to employee emotions and psychology. 

By implementing both employee recognition and reward programs, you’ll create a supportive and rewarding work environment for your staff. Leverage the recommendations above for the best results and to reduce employee turnover. 

One platform for culture, communication, and employee recognition.

See the Workmates Difference

FAQ’s

1. What’s the difference between employee rewards and recognition?

Answer: Rewards are tangible, often monetary or physical incentives (e.g., bonuses, gift cards, time-off) tied to specific achievements. Recognition is intangible, such as public praise or thank-you notes, aimed at emotionally acknowledging contributions.

2. Why are both rewards and recognition important?

Answer: Combined, they boost motivation, productivity, engagement, retention, and job satisfaction—rewards handle extrinsic incentives, while recognition addresses emotional needs.

3. What types of rewards are most effective?

Answer: Options that offer personalization and choice—like points-based systems redeemable for gift cards, experiences, or time-off—tend to drive stronger engagement and impact .

4. How should recognition be delivered to be meaningful?

Answer: It must be timely, specific, and linked to the behavior or outcome. Public shout-outs, written acknowledgments, and peer-to-peer praise are all effective methods .

5. How do you determine employees’ recognition preferences?

Answer: Use surveys and questionnaires asking about frequency, public vs private preference, types of recognition, etc. Sample questions include “What kind of recognition means the most to you?” .

6. How often should recognition occur?

Answer: Frequent, ongoing recognition (monthly or more) is key—regular, low-monetary gestures can be more effective than rare large rewards .

7. How do you build recognition into company culture?

Answer: Encourage everyday acknowledgement from managers and peers, integrate recognition into performance practices, and use platforms that allow social or peer-to-peer recognition .

8. How do you start a rewards & recognition program?

Answer:

1 . Define clear objectives and criteria aligned with company values and goals.

2. Choose the recognition method (manual, platform-based, peer-driven).

3. Set up monitoring and feedback, iterating based on survey insights.

Author Bio:

This article is written by a marketing team member at HR Cloud. HR Cloud is a leading provider of proven HR solutions, including recruiting, onboarding, employee communications & engagement, and rewards & recognition. Our user-friendly software increases employee productivity, delivers time and cost savings, and minimizes compliance risk.