HR Performance Improvement Plan: Role and Checklist

A manager writes the plan, an employee receives it, and HR is expected to make sure nothing about it comes back to hurt anyone. That is a lot to carry when the file you will be handed is a draft with three vague sentences and no dates. A well-run HR performance improvement plan process gives HR a defined job at each stage instead of a rescue role at the end.
Short answer: HR's role in a performance improvement plan is to set the process, coach the manager, check the plan before it is delivered, keep the record, follow up during the plan and document the outcome. The manager owns the plan and the day-to-day work. HR owns consistency, compliance checks and the file. This guide gives an owner table, a pre-plan compliance check, a documentation checklist, a draft review list, a follow-up cadence and a closing checklist.
It is written for HR generalists, HR business partners and people leaders who sign off on plans. It does not explain how to write the plan itself. For that, see our performance improvement plan template guide, format guide, form guide and letter guide. The compliance material covers US federal law only. It is not legal advice, and your counsel should review anything specific to your situation.
Key Takeaways
- HR's role has six parts: design the process, coach managers, check the plan before delivery, keep the record, follow up during the plan and document the outcome. Table 1 shows who owns what.
- Public sources agree the manager drafts the plan and HR reviews it. They differ on HR's part: SHRM's India site has HR coach and review, while Lattice has HR review and approve before delivery.
- Run a compliance check before the plan is issued. Look at prior complaints, leave, accommodation requests and whether the standard has been applied to others. Table 2 lists the checks and the federal source for each.
- Keep one complete file per plan: the plan, revisions, acknowledgment, coaching notes, check-in notes and the outcome summary. Table 3 gives the checklist.
- Follow-up is where HR plans fail. Set check-in dates and ask for written updates on a schedule, as Table 4 suggests.
- HR Cloud's Performance Management page describes goal tracking, check-ins, review cycles and review templates and, as of November 20, 2026, does not mention PIPs. Treat HR Cloud as a place to track goals and check-ins, not as a PIP tool.
What Is HR's Role in a Performance Improvement Plan?
HR is the process owner, the reviewer and the record keeper. The manager is the author and the day-to-day lead. The University of Richmond's HR page lists three HR duties: assist managers in assessing the situation, ensure compliance with university policies and coach managers in writing letters and having conversations with employees. Paycor's guide lists five: create a process, train managers, share relevant documents, document progress and communicate results.
The two lists describe the same split. HR sets up the structure and checks the work. The manager does the work.
SHRM's India site publishes an article by Martha Ekdahl arguing that HR should not own PIPs and that managers should write the first draft, with HR reviewing and coaching along the way. Lattice's process guide also has the manager draft the plan, but has HR review and approve it before delivery and keep the organization's system of record. Pick one model for HR's part and write it into your policy.
Table 1 is a suggested split of duties. It is a synthesis of the sources above and is not a standard. Adapt it to your policy.
| Stage | Manager | HR |
|---|---|---|
| Before the plan | Gathers examples and records. Considers whether the standard is reasonable | Runs the compliance check. Confirms policy and consistency with similar cases |
| Drafting | Writes the first draft | Coaches. Supplies the approved format and wording |
| Review | Revises | Reviews the draft for fairness, bias and clarity before delivery |
| Delivery | Leads the meeting. Gives the plan to the employee | Confirms the plan was delivered and acknowledged. Notes any refusal to sign |
| During the plan | Holds check-ins. Records each one | Follows up with the manager on a schedule. Reviews the notes |
| Closing | Recommends an outcome | Reviews the file. Confirms the outcome in writing. Files the record |
Table 1. A suggested split of PIP duties between manager and HR
Why this matters for HR: If HR writes every plan, managers learn nothing and HR becomes the bottleneck. If HR only sees the plan at the end, errors are found when they are hardest to fix.
What Should HR Check Before a PIP Is Issued?
Check the history, the alternatives and the legal context before the plan is drafted. The University of Richmond's steps begin with reviewing policy and gathering information: past performance reviews, prior disciplinary actions, and notes of previous conversations and disciplinary actions. HR can ask for the same package before it agrees to a plan.
Then ask whether a plan is the right tool. Emory's guidance says that if a supervisor lacks reasonable confidence that a PIP will lead to improved performance, a verbal warning may be more appropriate. AIHR says a PIP should not be used as a tick-box exercise and is most effective when there is a genuine belief that the employee can improve.
Then check the legal context. Table 2 lists checks drawn from US federal sources. They are starting points for a conversation with counsel, not a complete list. State and local laws, collective bargaining agreements and company policy add more.
| Check | Question for HR | Federal source |
|---|---|---|
| Consistent standards | Is the same standard applied to others in the same role? | EEOC guidance on performance and conduct standards says standards should be applied consistently to all employees |
| Disability and accommodation | Has the employee asked for an accommodation, or is a medical reason likely behind the gap? | EEOC (same guidance): the employee must meet the same production standards, an employer needs objective evidence before asking for medical information, and it need not excuse past poor performance |
| Protected activity | Has the employee recently complained, raised a concern or taken part in an EEO matter? | EEOC retaliation Q&A lists warnings, reprimands and lowered evaluations among actions that may be materially adverse, depending on the facts |
| Medical leave | Is the employee on, or recently back from, FMLA leave? | DOL Fact Sheet 77B: an employer cannot use a request for or use of FMLA leave as a negative factor in disciplinary actions |
| Independent view | Has someone who was not involved reviewed the decision? | EEOC says an employer may reduce the chance of retaliation by independently evaluating whether an adverse action is appropriate when a manager recommends one after protected activity |
Table 2. Compliance checks before a PIP, with the federal source for each
Two cautions apply. First, only the EEOC's disability guidance discusses PIPs by name, and the other federal sources describe disciplinary action in general, so ask counsel whether your plan could count as the kind of action each one describes. Second, these checks do not stop you from addressing real performance gaps. The EEOC's small business fact sheet says that engaging in EEO activity does not shield an employee from discipline or discharge, and gives poor job performance as an example of a non-retaliatory reason. The same fact sheet suggests having someone review the action to confirm it is appropriate and not motivated by retaliation, which is a check and not a bar on acting.
Hypothetical example: A branch manager asks HR to approve a plan for a loan processor whose error rate is above the team standard. In the compliance check, HR learns that the processor filed an internal complaint about a supervisor six weeks earlier. HR does not block the plan. It asks a second manager who was not involved to review the error data against the same measure for the other processors. The data shows the error rate is above the standard for this processor and no one else, and the second manager confirms the plan. HR records who reviewed it and what they found.
Pro tip: Ask for the checks in writing, as a short form the manager completes before the draft. A form that asks "any complaint, leave or accommodation request in the last twelve months?" gets answered. A verbal "anything I should know?" often does not.

What Documentation Should HR Keep for a PIP?
Keep one complete file per plan, in one place, with the same contents every time. Lattice's guide says to keep the full packet: the original plan, revisions, the acknowledgment, coaching notes, check-in notes and the final outcome summary, and to use one centralized system rather than scattered emails, spreadsheets and personal drives. Paycor says HR should keep detailed records of the employee's progress every step of the way, note managers' impressions and any relevant conversations with other company leaders, and include dates and times where possible.
Indiana University's PIP policy adds a point that is easy to miss. It tells supervisors to keep a PIP file that documents both improvements and continued deficiencies, and to encourage the employee to review it periodically. A file that records only the problems reads as a case being built. A file that records progress reads as a plan being run.
Table 3 turns those sources into a checklist.
| Item | What to keep | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-plan record | Past reviews, prior corrective actions, notes of earlier conversations, the compliance check | Shows the plan did not appear from nowhere |
| The plan | Final version and every revision, with dates | Shows what the employee was told and when |
| Delivery proof | Delivery date, method and the employee's acknowledgment, or a note of refusal to sign | Richmond says to note a refusal to sign on the document |
| Support provided | Training booked, resources given, meetings held | Shows the employer did what the plan said it would do |
| Check-in notes | Key discussion points, progress on goals and agreed next steps, after each meeting | Lattice recommends recording these after every meeting |
| Employee comments | Any response, disagreement or additional information from the employee | Shows the employee's view was heard |
| Outcome | The final review, the decision and the letter confirming it | Closes the record |
Table 3. A PIP file checklist for HR
Access matters as much as contents. Richmond's page says disciplinary action stays in the employee's file and only HR staff and the employee's supervisors can see it. Lattice describes role-based access so the right people see the right records. Decide who can open a PIP file before you start filling it.
Why a single file matters: When a plan is reviewed months later, a reader should not have to piece together what happened from three inboxes.
How Should HR Review a Draft PIP Before It Goes Out?
Read the draft as the employee would and as a reviewer outside the team would. Lattice's guide says HR should review and approve the plan before it is delivered, to make sure it is fair, compliant and consistent with how PIPs are handled elsewhere in the organization. In the SHRM India article on managers leading PIPs, Cris Barrett says HR can review the draft and give ideas to make it better. Arkansas's state guidance says to review the draft, preferably with an HR representative, before discussing it with the employee, and to meet in person where other employees cannot overhear. Brightmine adds that once a manager has drafted the plan, HR should review it to ensure it is appropriate, and that its template should be checked with local counsel for local legal requirements.
Use the list below. Each item can be answered yes or no.
- Is every concern tied to a date, a number and a record the employee can see?
- Is the standard the same one applied to others in the same role?
- Are the goals attainable in the time given, with the support listed?
- Does the plan name the support the employee will receive, with an owner and a date?
- Are the review dates written down, with a named person for each?
- Does the plan say what happens at the end, in words that match your policy?
- Does the plan avoid any reference to a personal trait, a leave, a complaint or a medical issue?
- Has a second person, not involved in the matter, read it?
- Does the acknowledgment line say received and discussed, not agreed?
For wording and layout questions, our letter guide and format guide go through them in detail.
Why a second reader helps: A reviewer who did not live the events reads only what is on the page. If the page does not support the plan, the employee will notice the same thing.
What Is HR's Role in the PIP Meeting?
HR's role in the meeting depends on your policy, so decide it in advance. Some organizations have HR attend. Others have the manager lead alone and HR prepare and follow up. The sources reviewed here do not set a single rule.
What the sources do cover is preparation and the handling of disagreement. G2's guidance for HR professionals suggests bringing the manager back for a final meeting before the employee meeting to review the plan section by section and be specific about the manager's role. Richmond's page says supervisors should give regular, constructive, objective and respectful feedback, and that if the employee disagrees, the manager should ask them to explain their view. Richmond also says that if the employee asks for a different supervisor, the manager should refer them to the HR business partner.
A short pre-meeting checklist for HR:
- Confirm the final plan and the acknowledgment line are ready.
- Brief the manager on what to say and what not to say. Our letter guide lists phrases to avoid.
- Agree who records the meeting and where the notes go.
- Agree what happens if the employee refuses to sign: note the refusal on the document and keep a copy.
- Agree where the employee goes with questions, so the manager is not the only contact.
Pro tip: Give the employee one HR contact by name. A person to ask is a support, and it also shows the plan has a process behind it.
How Often Should HR Follow Up During the Plan?
Set the schedule before the plan starts and put it on a calendar. Lattice recommends weekly or biweekly check-ins and says to record key discussion points, progress on goals and agreed next steps after each one. SHRM's India article says coaching managers includes checking in with them on progress during a PIP and asking open-ended questions. Leila Bulling Towne warns HR not to assume that a manager's "everything's going okay" means all is well.
HR's follow-up has two layers: the manager's check-ins with the employee, and HR's check-ins with the manager. Table 4 shows a suggested rhythm for a 60-day plan. It is a hypothetical schedule for illustration, not a standard, and the dates should follow your own plan.
| When | Who | What HR does |
|---|---|---|
| Day 0 | Manager, employee | Confirms delivery and acknowledgment are filed |
| Week 1 | Manager | Asks whether support has been provided as planned and checks the first notes |
| Weeks 2 to 4 (days 8 to 29) | Manager | Reviews notes for specifics, dates and progress against the measures |
| Day 30 | Manager, employee | Confirms the mid-point review took place and what it found |
| Days 31 to 55 | Manager | Asks open-ended questions about what has changed. Flags missing notes |
| Day 60 | Manager, employee | Reviews the final assessment before the outcome is communicated |
Table 4. A suggested HR follow-up rhythm for a hypothetical 60-day plan
The two layers matter because the gaps tend to appear in the second. A manager may hold the meetings and forget to write them down. Workalizer, a vendor of a Google Workspace performance tool, calls thin manager documentation a common challenge in its PIP documentation guide and suggests requiring managers to submit written updates to HR at a set frequency, such as weekly or biweekly. That is one company's advice, not a standard, but the logic is sound: if HR is not reading notes while the plan runs, the first time it learns the notes are thin is at the end.
Why check-ins need an owner: If nobody is assigned to ask for the notes, the notes will not exist when you need them.


How Should HR Close Out a PIP?
Close the plan with a written outcome, a reviewed file and a conversation, in that order. Lattice's guide lists a final outcome summary as part of the record, and Paycor lists communicating results as an HR duty. The outcomes your policy allows should be written down in advance, so the closing step applies the policy and does not invent one.
Policies vary, but many cover outcomes like these. Indiana University's policy, for example, covers a successful plan, continuing, amending or extending the plan, and corrective action. Table 5 shows what HR checks for each, plus the case where the employee leaves. The outcome names are a common pattern and not a standard, so match them to your own policy.
| Outcome | What HR checks before it is confirmed | What goes in the file |
|---|---|---|
| Plan completed, performance met | Every measure was assessed against the same standard written in the plan | Final assessment and a short letter confirming the plan is closed |
| Plan extended | The reason for the extension is specific, and the new dates and measures are written | A revised plan with a new acknowledgment line |
| Further action | The file supports the decision, the compliance checks from Table 2 are repeated, and a second reviewer has read it | The final assessment, the review record and the decision letter |
| Employee leaves during the plan | Any pending questions about final records, access to the file and references are answered per policy | A note of the date and circumstances, per policy |
Table 5. A closing checklist by outcome
Repeat the compliance check at the end. Something may have changed since the plan began: a leave, an accommodation request, a complaint. If it has, the same questions in Table 2 apply to the closing decision, not only the opening one.
Then hold the closing conversation. Give the employee the final assessment in writing, explain the outcome in plain language, and say what happens next. If the outcome is positive, say what regular performance conversations look like from here. A plan that ends without a clear next step leaves the employee guessing.
Why the closing matters: The end of a plan is the part most likely to be read later by someone else. Make sure it explains itself.
Hypothetical example: A 40-person warehouse runs a 60-day plan for a shift lead whose inventory counts missed the accuracy target. At day 60, the manager recommends extending the plan by 30 days because accuracy reached the target in the last three weeks but not before. HR checks the notes, finds the improvement documented week by week, and confirms the extension is consistent with how the policy has been applied to two earlier plans. The revised plan states the new end date, keeps the same target and is acknowledged in writing.
What Mistakes Do HR Teams Make in a PIP?
Most problems come from thin records and unclear ownership, not from bad intent. The list below is a synthesis of the guidance reviewed here. It is not a research finding, and the sources do not rank these mistakes.
- Treating the plan as paperwork. AIHR warns against using a PIP as a tick-box exercise. If the outcome is already decided, say so and use the right process instead.
- Reviewing the plan only at the end. Errors in goals, dates and wording are cheap to fix before delivery and expensive after.
- No notes between meetings. Lattice says to record key points after every check-in. A meeting that was held but not recorded is hard to prove later.
- Recording only the negatives. Indiana University's policy says the file should show improvements and continued deficiencies. A one-sided file weakens the plan.
- Unclear access. If anyone can open the file, or no one knows where it is, the problem is a process one and HR owns it.
Pro tip: Once a quarter, pull a closed plan file at random and check it against Table 3. Gaps in the file show you where the process is slipping.
Where Does HR Cloud Fit?
What HR Cloud's Performance Management page describes is goal tracking, check-ins, review cycles and review templates, and as of November 20, 2026 it does not describe a PIP feature. This guide does not claim one. Those can help a team keep targets and conversations visible before a plan is ever needed. For the plan itself, use the formats and wording in our template guide, format guide and letter guide. For the terms, see the glossary entry on PIPs.
The HR Performance Improvement Plan in Short
A strong HR performance improvement plan process gives each stage an owner. The manager writes and leads. HR checks the context before the plan, reviews the draft, keeps one file, follows up on a schedule and confirms the outcome in writing. The tables above turn that into a split of duties, a compliance check, a file checklist, a follow-up rhythm and a closing checklist.
Start small. Pick one table, adapt it to your policy and use it on the next plan. Then ask counsel to review your process for the legal points that depend on your state and your workforce. This guide covers US federal sources only and is not legal advice.
Discover how our HR solutions streamline onboarding, boost employee engagement, and simplify HR management
Book a DemoFrequently Asked Questions
What is HR's role in a performance improvement plan?
HR sets the process, coaches the manager, checks the plan before delivery, keeps the record, follows up during the plan and documents the outcome. The manager writes the plan and leads the work. HR owns consistency, compliance checks and the file. Your written policy should say who does what.
Should HR write the PIP or the manager?
Lattice and SHRM's India site both have the manager draft the plan. They differ on HR's part: SHRM's India site has HR review and coach, while Lattice has HR review and approve before delivery. Either model works if your policy names one and applies it consistently.
Should HR attend the PIP meeting?
It depends on your policy, and the sources reviewed here do not set a single rule. Some organizations have HR attend. Others have the manager lead and HR prepare and follow up. Whichever you choose, apply it the same way each time, and make sure the employee knows one HR contact by name.
What should HR check before approving a PIP?
Check that concerns are tied to dates and records, that the same standard applies to others in the role, and that there is no recent complaint, leave or accommodation request that needs a closer look. Then ask whether someone not involved has read the plan. Table 2 lists the federal sources behind each check.
What documents should HR keep for a PIP?
Keep one file with the pre-plan record, the final plan and revisions, proof of delivery and acknowledgment, support provided, check-in notes, any employee comments and the outcome. Include improvements as well as problems. Decide in advance who can open the file, and keep it in one system.
How often should HR follow up during a PIP?
Set the schedule before the plan starts. Lattice recommends weekly or biweekly check-ins between manager and employee. HR should read the manager's notes on a regular rhythm, such as the one in Table 4, and ask open-ended questions rather than accept that things are going fine.
Can an employee on FMLA leave be placed on a PIP?
Not on the basis of leave. DOL Fact Sheet 77B says an employer cannot use a request for or use of FMLA leave as a negative factor in disciplinary actions. A performance issue unrelated to leave may be addressed, but HR should review the facts with counsel before issuing the plan.
What if the employee asks for an accommodation during a PIP?
Take the request seriously and begin the interactive process. The EEOC's disability guidance says an employer need not cancel a PIP or excuse past poor performance, but must still provide a reasonable accommodation that would help future performance. Document the request and the response, and involve counsel early.
About the author

Like What You Hear?
We’d love to chat with you more about how HR Cloud® can support your business’s HR needs.
Book Your Free Demo

